Libel reform
In April 2008 Simon Singh published an article in the Guardian in which he explored the use of Chiropractic to treat, amongst other things, childhood asthma. The British Chiropractic Association (BCA) took issue with the article, and refused to be satisfied with an offer to print a counter to it. Instead, citing a “substantial evidence supporting the claim they make on their website that their members can help treat children with colic, sleeping and feeding problems, frequent ear infections, asthma and prolonged crying (Beware the spinal trap, page 26, April 19),” they decided to sue Simon personally for defamation.
Even if he won, it would likely cost Simon £50,ooo, but if he lost the costs could easily be ten times that. Simon felt that the matter was one of public interest, and after taking legal advice decided to fight the case. In May 2009 the judge made a ruling that hurt Simon’s case, saying that a key statement in the article was one of fact, and not of comment. This made the case a lot harder to defend. Simon chose to go to the Court of Appeal, his least worst option, where he would argue that the judge misconstrued his article. That raised the costs even higher.
Britain is renowned as having the most libel-friendly laws in the world. It is easy for organizations to threaten individuals with a libel suit that will be expensive to win and more expensive to lose. It makes it hard even to question an organization that might be responsible for bad science. That is not something I want Britain to be famous for. Nor am I alone. Simon is being supported by a charitable organization called Sense about Science, with a web site where you can also read full details of his case.
You can help
The best thing we can do to help is to get the political parties to make a manifesto commitment to reform libel law. A petition has been started in an attempt to raise at least 100,000 signatures, and let politicians know that we demand reform. Remember:
All that is necessary for bad science to triumph is that good politicians do nothing.
Don’t give them any excuse to do nothing. Sign the petition.




